Sunday, December 18, 2011

The controversy trailing the move
by the Federal Government to
remove subsidy on oil continues. It
has become a ding dong affair and
has sharply torn the country into
two-those for and against.
In the public domain, the argument
has reached fever pitch.
Many contend that the Federal
Government should make practical
and genuine efforts toward
addressing the problem of poverty
in the country rather than imposing
policies that would further
compound it. For a greater
percentage of the population, it is
unthinkable to toy with the subsidy
on oil considering the economic
burden on the common man
already.
And characteristic of Nigeria,
petroleum products are already
becoming scarce and queues have
surfaced in filling stations across the
country in anticipation of the price
increase. There are fears that the
country which has lately become
volatile could further be engulfed
by more crises. For those in this
school of thought, the future is
bleak. But there is also the critical
minority, especially those in the
corridors of power who believe that
the decision is inevitable at the
moment. For instance, the National
Economic Council (NEC) toes the line
of the Federal Government on the
removal of subsidy, saying that it is
inevitable at the moment.
The council chaired by the Vice
President, Alhaji Namadi Sambo,
having the 36 State Governors and
some cabinet ministers as
members, is the highest economic
decision-making body of the
government. Making the council’s
position known recently to State
House Correspondents after the NEC
meeting in Abuja, Governor Peter
Obi of Anambra State, was
unequivocal that the removal of
the subsidy would enable the
Federal Government service its
debt portfolio.
“It is a case of inevitability,
considering the level of present
debt portfolio of the Federal
Government and the continuous
financing of it.“Like President
Goodluck Jonathan said, either way,
there will be grave consequences
and one is lesser if we take it. There
is no place such decision has been
taken that people do not feel a
temporary pain,’’ he said. So, as it
is, the opponents and proponents
of subsidy removal sound quite
convincing in their arguments.
And interestingly, both sides of the
divide claim to be making a case in
the interest of the people and for
the survival of the country. But the
man at the centre of the impasse is
President Goodluck Jonathan who is
blowing hot and cold. This week, he
was quoted in the media to have
expressed readiness for mass
revolt in the event of government
removing the oil subsidy. President
Jonathan was said to have made
the remark during a meeting with
the leadership of some civil society
organizations at the presidential
villa, Abuja. But in what appeared
like a volte face, the president
resolved to make further
consultations before taking the final
decision.
Coordinating Minister for the
Economy and Minister of Finance,
Dr. Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala, disclosed
on Thursday that Jonathan was still
consulting with major stakeholders
and would announce his decision on
the issue at the end of the
consultations.“Mr. President is
consulting widely on the subsidy
issue. He has been consulting with
various stakeholders in the country,
including private sector operators,
students, religious leaders and
others. At the end of the wide
consultation, we will give him room
to take a decision,” she said at the
briefing on the 2012 budgetary
allocations in Abuja.
Many argue that the president is
faced with a “devil’s alternative”.
The Otuoke born former lecturer is
between the devil and the deep
blue sea. If he listens to the wishes
of the majority and drops the idea
of oil subsidy removal, a critical
segment of the nation would
further see him as a man who lacks
the political will to take a bold step.
But if he goes on with removal of
subsidy, many would see him in
the mould of successive leaders
who churned out policies that have
now become a burden on the
citizenry.
So, as it appears, President
Jonathan will be the loser, head or
tail but according to William Pollard,
“It is not always what we know or
analyzed before we make a
decision that makes it a great
decision. It is what we do after we
make the decision to implement
and execute it that makes it a
good decision.” Another great
thinker, Mike Myatt, argues that,
“as a leader, you will live or die by
the quality of the decisions you
make”.
According to him, “when you’re the
leader, good decisioning is
expected, poor decisioning won’t be
tolerated, and great decisioning will
set you apart from the masses.”
And not withstanding the merits
and demerits of the oil subsidy
removal, many argue that there is
more to it than meets the eye. But
what are they?
For sometime, the issue of oil
subsidy has become a recurring
decimal. From one government to
the other, the issue has dominated
public discourse. In1986, former
Head of State, General Ibrahim
Babangida toyed with the idea of
increasing fuel price.
The citizenry were unanimous in
the fight against IBB. It will be
recalled that the students of
University of Jos rose in their might
against IBB’s administration’s
proposal and coincidentally, the
students were led by Mr. Labaran
Maku, current Minister of
information and National
Orientation who is now one of
those advocating the oil subsidy
removal.
During Obasanjo’s administration,
the price of petroleum products
was increased many times with the
last being a day before the
expiration of his tenure. Many had
thought then that Obasanjo’s last
minute increase in fuel price was
the height of insensitivity of his
administration against the masses.
And just like his predecessors, since
President Jonathan emerged, he
has not hidden his belief in the
removal of subsidy on oil.
Driving home his reason on
Thursday in Abuja, he said that fuel
subsidy removal would only bring
temporary pains which will fizzle
out in no time for Nigerians to reap
the gains. Speaking at the 2011
Christmas Carol held at the Banquet
Hall of the Presidential Villa, he
argued that the nation could not
continue to use its limited resources
to subsidise imported fuel.
He said the fuel subsidy was to the
advantage of a cartel and to the
detriment of the poor masses. The
president explained that the
decision by his administration to
remove fuel subsidy was in the
overall interest of the nation and
not a deliberate move to inflict
pains on the people. ``There is
nobody who will want to
deliberately inflict suffering on his
people. Goodluck Jonathan can
never be one.
``I know the pains Nigerians are
passing through. Yes, I am here in
the State House and being fed by
government but that does not
keep me so far from the people.
``There is no day that I don’t
interact with Nigerians, both low
and high, and I appreciate the pains
of the people. We are facing
challenges but we must take
certain decisions to reposition our
economy so that things will ease
out.
``If we don’t have the courage to
do so, then we will continue to be
dying in pains until God knows
when.
``So, my belief is that, at a
particular time, people must be
courageous to take the right
decisions,’’ he said. Despite his
effort to justify the move, the
argument by the majority is that
the removal of subsidy now would
further worsen the plight of the
already suffering masses and could
create tension of unimaginable
proportion in the country. In the
estimation of many, with the
current insecurity in the country,
the removal of fuel subsidy has the
potential to inflame the already
charged socio-economic and
political atmosphere in Nigeria.
But for critical observers, the move
by the Federal Government is
meant to engender competition
among private companies. A point
of reference here is the Nigerian
Telecommunications (NITEL), before
its deregulation. The expectation is
that like what happened in the
telecommunications industry, when
the door to the downstream sector
is flung open, petrol may sell very
high but will drop to the barest
minimum at the height of
competition.
Many believe that when the oil
subsidy is removed, money saved
from the policy would now be used
to address social needs like free
and quality health care, education,
massive infrastructure
development and so on. To lend
credence to the argument for
removal of the subsidy, the
Manufacturers’ Association of
Nigeria (MAN) expressed its support
for the government’s plan but said
it must be in phases starting in
January 2012.
MAN President, Kola Jamodu, was
quoted in the media as saying the
removal was necessary for the
growth of the country’s economy.
But the caveat in his statement is
that proceeds from the withdrawal
of the subsidy must be properly
utilised to accelerate development
of key infrastructure such as
electricity and roads.
The position of MAN which is a
critical group in the nation’s
economy came even though the
Nigeria Labour Congress (NLC), the
Trade Union Congress (TUC), the
opposition parties and some
concerned Nigerians have, on their
own part, been harping on the
pains of the impending subsidy
removal.
They warn that the subsidy will
cause inflation and lead to loss of
jobs in an economy where the
rates of unemployment and
poverty are already high. They
fear that such development will in
turn lead to social unrest and
threaten the fragile stability of a
country still grappling with the high
incidence of insecurity.

No comments:

Post a Comment